Attachment theory suggests that our earliest relationships, particularly those with caregivers, lay the groundwork for how we connect with others throughout life. Two of the primary attachment styles that can develop as a result of early developmental trauma are anxious attachment and avoidant attachment. While these styles seem contradictory—one craving closeness and reassurance, the other resisting emotional intimacy—many individuals exhibit behaviors associated with both. This coexistence is often a direct result of earlier traumatic experiences.
Anxious attachment is marked by a fear of abandonment and a strong need for emotional closeness and validation. Individuals with this attachment style often worry that their needs will not be met, leading to clinginess, hypervigilance, and constant attempts to seek reassurance from others. Avoidant attachment, on the other hand, is characterized by discomfort with intimacy and a tendency to pull away from emotional closeness. Avoidantly attached individuals often downplay their needs, suppress emotions, and seek to maintain independence, fearing that reliance on others may lead to disappointment or loss of control.
Developmental trauma, such as inconsistent caregiving, emotional neglect, or abuse during early childhood, profoundly impacts attachment, whether avoidant or anxious. These traumatic experiences disrupt the ability to form secure bonds with caregivers, leading to maladaptive attachment patterns. For children exposed to inconsistent caregiving—where caregivers may oscillate between being available and emotionally distant—both anxious and avoidant strategies may develop. Children in these environments learn to adapt to unpredictable relationships, employing different attachment strategies to manage the instability. At times, they might seek closeness (anxious attachment) to ensure the caregiver’s attention; at other times, they might distance themselves (avoidant attachment) to avoid the pain of rejection or abandonment.
The coexistence of anxious and avoidant attachment styles is often referred to as disorganized attachment or fearful-avoidant attachment. These individuals are caught in a cycle of needing connection but also fearing it.
There are several ways this manifests:
1. Approach-Avoidance Conflict: Individuals may feel an intense longing for closeness but push others
away when that intimacy is available. This internal conflict is rooted in early trauma, where caregivers may have been both a source of comfort and fear. The individual’s nervous system becomes hypervigilant, unsure whether to approach or avoid relationships, leading to erratic behavior in intimate connections.
2. Hyperactivation and Deactivation of Attachment Systems: Trauma survivors often toggle between hyperactivating their attachment system (anxious behaviors like clinging or excessive reassurance-seeking) and deactivating it (avoidant behaviors like emotional withdrawal or stonewalling). This is a survival mechanism developed in response to unpredictable or unsafe caregiving environments.
3. Internalized Conflicting Beliefs: These individuals may hold two conflicting beliefs about relationships: the anxious side believes, "I need you to survive," while the avoidant side believes, "If I let you close, you will hurt me." This internal tug-of-war creates a paradoxical dynamic where they simultaneously crave intimacy and push it away, resulting in frustration and confusion for both themselves and their partners.
4. Fear of Vulnerability: Developmental trauma often fosters a deep-seated fear of vulnerability. People with both anxious and avoidant tendencies fear being emotionally open, as it exposes them to rejection, shame, or abandonment. They may show vulnerability briefly, only to retreat into emotional withdrawal soon after, as the fear of being hurt resurfaces.
Developmental trauma fundamentally shapes how individuals relate to themselves and others. Those with both anxious and avoidant tendencies often develop complex strategies to manage the emotional consequences of trauma. This includes emotional dysregulation, difficulty trusting others, and chronic self-doubt. Trauma can distort one’s perception of relationships, leading to repeated cycles of attachment seeking and avoidance as a means of self-protection.
Healing from the effects of developmental trauma and coexisting attachment styles involves:
1. Awareness and Insight: The first step toward healing is understanding the origins of these attachment styles. Therapy provides a safe space for individuals to explore the connection between their early relationships and current behaviors. Trauma-informed approaches, such as somatic therapy and mindfulness, help individuals reconnect with their bodies and emotions, allowing them to safely process and release trauma stored in the nervous system.
2. Self-Compassion and Emotional Regulation: Learning self-compassion is crucial for healing, as individuals with these attachment styles often harbor self-blame or shame for their relational struggles. Developing emotional regulation skills, through modalities like Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) and Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), helps manage the intense emotions triggered by attachment conflicts.
3. Developing Secure Relationships: Healing also involves gradually building secure relationships with trustworthy individuals. These relationships provide corrective emotional experiences, showing that emotional intimacy can be safe and reliable. Trust-building and communication are essential to help the individual feel seen and valued without triggering their avoidant defenses.
4. Integrating the Parts: Trauma-focused therapies such as the Developmental Needs Meeting Strategy (DNMS) can help individuals recognize the different parts of themselves—both the anxious and avoidant parts. By understanding these parts as adaptive strategies rather than flaws, individuals can work toward integrating them, fostering a more coherent and secure attachment style.
The coexistence of anxious and avoidant attachment styles is a complex but understandable response to developmental trauma. While the behaviors associated with these styles can create difficulties in relationships, they are ultimately survival strategies formed in the context of early caregiving experiences. Through trauma-informed therapy and self-awareness, individuals can move toward greater emotional balance, deeper connections, and a more secure attachment style.
Are you ready for this important work?
Comments